Free Credit Report

motor HP for 16-18' flat bottom aluminum boat for trolling?

I'm looking to fish the Muskie reservoirs in Ohio. Thinking about a boat that provides maximum opportunity at minimum price. I'm looking to outfit a 16-18' flat bottom aluminum boat with some rod holders for trolling and a < 10 HP outboard so I can use it in some of the power restricted areas. If I want to use the outboard for trolling, what size do you recommend? (Optimal trolling is more important to me than getting around quickly.)

Any other equipment hints or tips will be much appreciated.

Thanks,

Michael Courtney

Courtney
Oct 19
2005
How fast will you troll for Muskies? How fast will the 10HP push the boat? Trolling for striped bass in the Ches. Bay is done about 3 mph. Trolling for spanish mackerel is done from 5-6 mph. I would think the 10HP would push your boat that fast.

-- John H

"The trouble with our liberal friends is not that they're ignorant: It's just that they know so much that isn't so." Ronald Reagan

PocoLoco
Oct 19
You are going to be trolling big plugs with heavy gear so 9.9 is probably what you are looking for.

You could probably get away with a 6, but the price/performance difference isn't going to be significant. In my experience, the larger engines give you a little more control over boat speed and handling that smaller engines don't.

As to type, all the majors except Evinrude make a 9.9 in various iteration - four and two stroke with two strokes becoming more rare. Price considerations are important so you want to look at Suzuki - their pricing is very aggressive and the Suzuki engines are excellent and reliable. Yamahamhamhammhaahmaahmaaamahahahaha makes a four stroke and Merc markets a four stroke in this size but I don't know who makes it. Johnson has a four stroke which is made by Suzuki or Yamaha - I can't remember which. Hondas are great, but expensive and you really don't want to ever have a problem with one - fixing them is somewhat problematic unless you have a really experienced Honda outboard mechanic in the area.

In this situation where slow roll trolling is important, consider a four stroke for a couple of reasons. If you are trolling with the wind, the emissions aren't as bad as they are with a two stroke. And they are much quieter than two strokes in this size.

Other than that, it's just a question of price of the engine, what kind of boat and the long/short shaft deal.

Pretty much about it.

Shortwave
Oct 20
Guess you guys troll way faster down there than we do!

You might attract a coho at idle with a 9.9, but it's WAY too fast for a trout. We all use electric trolling motors around here: much more variable (a 40-lb Minn Kota would push your boat anywhere from 0 to 4-5mph) Cheaper than an outboard, easier on the environment, easier to sneak up on wary fish...

Lloyd Sumpter "Near Cove III" Brig 9.5 c/w Max55T

Lloyd
Oct 19
This is a Muksie:

http://muskie.outdoorsfirst.com/

It is an entirely different fish than a trout.

Shortwave
Oct 20
   

Disclaimer: This is a computer-generated and formatted feed of current postings to a public
Internet forum. We do not control the information delivered, nor do we endorse or monitor its
content. Internet forums may carry offensive, harmful, inaccurate, and otherwise inappropriate material.
Click to see the RSS XML version of this page   Click to see the Atom XML version of this page