Free Credit Report

Diesel Engine Choice?

Can't afford to run gas engines in my preferred tonnage of boat, even though gas engine boats are usually tens of thousands of dollars cheaper at the start. Thinking about replacing gas engines or buying a boat with.

Been through Pascoe and all that. Have been a fan of gas engines all my life and would stick with 'em if it weren't insane at this point. Gasoline isn't that much more expensive but diesels are simply better on consumption.

I'm talking about pushing around a 25,000+# vessel with a planing hull but perhaps just pushing it around at hull speed or slightly above.

Seen lots of different diesels in boats. Cummins, Detroit, Perkins, Volvo, Hino, Yanmar, Mann, John Deere and, of course, Cat in natural and turbo.

The major differences I understand are:

2-cycle vs. 4-cycle Natural vs. turbo Aluminum vs. steel Piston sleeves or not

If you were advising someone on what to look for/avoid, in either new or used diesels, what would you say???

Thanks in advance,

jps

jps
Apr 13
2006
Thanks Gene. Which brand?

I don't think Cats have sleeves, Cummins are aluminum, Perkins?

I know Hino's have sleeves.

Any faves?

jps

jps
Apr 15
At least some of the Volvo's have sleeves. Mine does, but are turbo'd six cylinders.

But, a naturally aspirated small diesel is likely to last a long, long time. Replaceable sleeves may not be all that important. At 6000+ hours the original Ford Lehman in my wife's Grand Banks is just broken in according to Bob Smith of American Diesel Corp.

RCE

RCE
Apr 15
following thoughts:

IMHO...

4-cycle, Natural, steel, Piston sleeves

Gene
Apr 14
A lot has changed in Diesels in the past few years. One source you should look at is www.boatdiesel.com, for $25/yr you can 'join' and see all their archives. The past few months are free :-)

-al-

On Thu, 13 Apr 2006 20:20:52 -0700, jps <trash@thedump.com> wrote:

Al
Apr 14
   

Disclaimer: This is a computer-generated and formatted feed of current postings to a public
Internet forum. We do not control the information delivered, nor do we endorse or monitor its
content. Internet forums may carry offensive, harmful, inaccurate, and otherwise inappropriate material.
Click to see the RSS XML version of this page   Click to see the Atom XML version of this page