Free Credit Report

How far offshore would be reasonable from the Jersey shore? '98 Sea Ray Sundancer 25',

I just purchased a '98 Sundancer 250 with a single 5.7 EFI/Bravo III. The boat is in excellent condition, and a full hull and engine survey proved it was quite the solid boat, with many hours to go on it. While sitting waiting up here in the northeast for the weather to warm up I keep reading more and more about fishing off the Jersey shore. I have read articles about catching Tuna, Dolphin and all sorts of interesting fish in locations like the Mud hole, which is 15 miles offshore. I purchased the boat primarily as a Hudson river and bay boat for the family, but would love to venture to deeper waters to do some fishing with my freinds.

Now I know prior to making any excursion that is outside a somewhat controlled environemnt (i.e. Hudson river), I really have to get comfortable with the boat and know how it handles, as well as how I can handle it. The boat is pretty loaded with VHF, Compass, GPS/ Sounder, and your common safety equipment. So if I can maybe gather some opinions to the following it would be greatly appreciated.

- How far offshore is reasonable in this style, size, and equipped boat?

- What else should I consider getting to ensure any offshore trip would be a safe one?

- Are there any places or clubs to meet up with other boaters heading out to the hot fishing spots that might allow someone less experienced to follow them out? (This would offer a level of safety that if something did go wrong there are other boats in the area)

Thanks in advance. I am excited to get in the water, the waiting is killing me. I assume if your reading this newsgroup in February you are also as eager to see the thermometor tip some warmer numbers.

MJK

King5899
Feb 7
An excellent illustration of the point that twins don't always make a boat safer. With twin inboards, the shaft aft of the shaft log is perilously exposed. I'd be willing to bet that more sinkings occur each year due to ripping a strut away from the hull (and creating a 2-3 sq ft (!) breach) than from a loss of motive power. Losing headway won't usually put a boat into peril unless there is a pretty nasty blow going on- but ripping off a strut upon striking a deadhead, a hawser, a reef, a whale, etc can easily sink a boat in a dead calm.

For my money, I like the shaft protruding about a foot or so from the cutlass bearing, protected by a keel, skeg, and rudder. Much safer than running naked.

Chuck
Feb 9
No, not "always". But having twins improves your chances. If the engine Eisboch
Feb 9
I think twins are important if you are a gas boat. Less important for a diesel. Once you get a diesel started it will run until you shut it off unless it overheats (entirely preventable) or is denied combustible fuel. (Fuel problems tend to affect both engines, so twins are less of an issue from that perspective). Witness- nearly every commercial fishing boat ever built; offshore for sometimes a couple of weeks and running with a single diesel. May be less true than before, with all of the intricate comptuerization now incorporated into a modern diesel- but I suspect in most cases a diesel would continue to run if the electronics crapped out- just wouldn't run very well.

And of course, don't leave the dock without a VHF and a decent antenna.

I agree with your point of diesel vs gas although modern diesels are increasingly reliant on electronics to run. There are, however, other propulsion system failures or accidents that could leave you dead in the water while doing offshore cruising and/or fishing. IMO being dead in the water, 30 or 40 miles from land in rough seas is second only to fire in terms of danger.

Eisboch

RCE
Feb 8
Do new boaters still get all nervous about passing through Plum Gut on a quiet day, or don't you get out that way at all? JoeSpareBedroom
Feb 8
Yes, new boaters are nervous about the Plum Gut and I go there all the time. It's a hop, skip and a jump from the Stonington launch ramp at Barn Island. Short
Feb 8
My sister considered it to be like an amusement park ride. But, she was not the owner of the boat. :-) JoeSpareBedroom
Feb 8
Hooking up with a decent sized mako and having it jump into the boat is one that I've actually witnessed.

Funniest "accident" I've ever seen. The fish was flopping around the stern and three guys hanging onto the top of the console and the T-Top.

I know a guy who had the prop shaft supports ripped out the bottom of his boat by a whale that came out of nowhere - hit the stern and everything went bye-bye.

Fortunately, it didn't sink - some quick thinking bystanders came to the guys rescue with some tarps, the CG sent a pump and two bigger boats came alongside and limped the owners boat in until Sea//Tow could get to it.

Short
Feb 8
We met up with some guys in a big Sea Ray on the voyage to Florida and did some partying at the marina we stopped at. The next day (nursing hangovers) we elected to stay on the ICW and they decided to run off-shore.

They ended up wrapping a submerged chunk of 2" hawser on one of their shafts and ripped the cutlass bearing mounting plate right out of the hull. Fortunately they were able to stuff the hole enough and maintain headway on the other engine until the Coast Guard arrived.

Eisboch

RCE
Feb 8
I know boaters who think running the East Passage of Narraganset Bay in a SW wind seas 4 to 6 as fun.

While I've done it, I didn't consider it fun.

Short
Feb 8
Don't remember that, but since I was a kid, I probably just imprinted stuff that would've made for a good sitcom.

- Wandering into that submarine practice zone, IIRC west of Block Island. Dad said "Nah..that's not where we are." I'd just taken the power squadron course, and I was positive we were in the zone. We're puttering along, trolling for stripers or something, and a half mile away, a sub surfaces, contacts us, and politely re-educates my dad. I said nothing. I don't know what he was thinking. Maybe "Hey - I'm ex-Navy. I'm allowed".

- Demo of why plastic dishes are good on boats: Dad didn't care if winds from a certain direction always meant crazy water (even for a 42' Owens). Ex torpedo bomber pilots have no fear, apparently. So, one day, north of Orient Point, things got interesting. The boat was all over the place. The first sign of trouble was when my mom's stoneware dishes became too much for the latches on the cabinets below. Big noise, all dishes declared dead. Then, my sister brings the Chapman book up to the bridge and points out the artist's rendering of pitchpoling. She had a weird sense of timing. My younger sister slept through the whole thing.

- Townsend marina, Greenport: Dad & mechanic standing in bilge of 32' Luhrs, 95 degrees, mosquitoes as thick as pea soup, oil up to their ankles. I must've been nagging him for bait money or some such thing - I don't recall. He climbs out of the bilge, says "Get over here", I follow him to the bow, where he picks me up and tosses me into the water. Much laughter from adjacent boats. No more kid noise till engine was fixed. :-)

JoeSpareBedroom
Feb 8
It's amazing how much stuff like that is out there, most of it floating polypropolene line and netting from commercial fishing boats.

We heard a distress conversation 2 years ago between a 110 ft Broward and the coast guard. They had become entangled in floating line somewhere off the Carolina coast and were dead in the water.

Wayne.B
Feb 8
For the benefit of the OP, the Hudson is loaded with chunks of wood, and sometimes entire trees. There are so many so-called "creeks" that empty into the river, many of them big enough to carry lots of debris, especially during the spring thaw and a month or three afterward. This is why many of the creeks were used for moving lumber. JoeSpareBedroom
Feb 8
It all depends on the weather, wind and sea state. I've crossed Cape Cod Bay RCE
Feb 8
~~ snip ~~ Short
Feb 8
The Sundancer 250 is a good river and bay boat but you will soon discover that it has its limitations there also. It was not designed as an off shore boat so it is severly weather limited for that use.

I agree with all of the previous advice: radar, liferaft, EPIRB, kicker engine, navigation courses, SeaTow membership, etc.

In addition, I would encourage you to get a lot more experience with the boat and its equipment. Over time you will get a much better appreciation for what it can and can not do safely, and you will gain experience in how to manage difficult conditions.

The Jersey shore is a dangerous place in conditions that are only moderately severe. The inlets can have breaking seas even when the wind is not blowing, all it takes is a large swell and an outgoing tide. 25 foot boats get rolled and people lost every year after getting caught by an inopportune breaking wave.

Wayne.B
Feb 8
Great point. It's like working the Charlestown Breachway. Perfectly calm day outside, six foot breakers on the tide going into.

Tough to do in a smallish boat.

Short
Feb 8
>calm day outside, six foot breakers on the tide going into. > >Tough to do in a smallish boat.

Especially when you are upside down with people in the water.

People who are moving up from smaller boats tend to think of a 25 footer as being large. I used to, because most of my time on the water as a kid was spent in 14 to 17 ft runabouts.

However even with our new SeaRay 270 it is still pretty easy to get beat up on open water. We were out on the Gulf of Mexico two weeks ago with just a moderate 12 kt breeze, and that was plenty. Not dangerous by any means, but rough enough to require a substantial speed reduction.

Now if I still had my old Bertram 33, it would have been damn the torpedoes...

Wayne.B
Feb 8
I think twins are important if you are a gas boat. Less important for a diesel. Once you get a diesel started it will run until you shut it off unless it overheats (entirely preventable) or is denied combustible fuel. (Fuel problems tend to affect both engines, so twins are less of an issue from that perspective). Witness- nearly every commercial fishing boat ever built; offshore for sometimes a couple of weeks and running with a single diesel. May be less true than before, with all of the intricate comptuerization now incorporated into a modern diesel- but I suspect in most cases a diesel would continue to run if the electronics crapped out- just wouldn't run very well.

And of course, don't leave the dock without a VHF and a decent antenna.

Chuck
Feb 8
   

Disclaimer: This is a computer-generated and formatted feed of current postings to a public
Internet forum. We do not control the information delivered, nor do we endorse or monitor its
content. Internet forums may carry offensive, harmful, inaccurate, and otherwise inappropriate material.
Click to see the RSS XML version of this page   Click to see the Atom XML version of this page