Free Credit Report

Price of Diesel vs Petrol engines?

Over here in Switzerland they seem to charge a lot for Diesel engines. eg 2xVolvo D3-160 DP (160hp/120kW)vs 2x Mercruiser 5.0l MPI Bravo III (260hp/194 kW) is an additional 12'000 EUR/16'000 USD or 2xVolvo D4-260 DP (260hp/191kW)vs 2x Mercruiser 350 MAG MPI Bravo III (300hp/224 kW) is an additional 30'000 EUR/40'000 USD.

What do you pay for a Diesel over a Petrol/Gasoline engine? eg what is the premium for Diesel for two engines in the 190kW/255hp range?

TIA

Marc

May 15
Here in the US diesels are typically 50 to 100% more costly. Maintenance costs are higher also, mostly due to higher parts and labor. Wayne.B
May 15
True, but the traditonally longer lifespans of diesel engines mean that in many cases the same engine can remain in a vessel for the life of the boat while gas engines will need more frequent rebuilds or replacements. 8-10 years from now, the *second* gas engine might cost as much as a diesel would have cost today. (This may not be as universally true with some of the new lightweight, higher RPM diesels that probably won't go 4000, 5000, 6000 hours or more before MOH). Fuel costs are lower with a diesel, and resale values often substantially higher. Try to sell a gas engine boat with 1200 hours on it and you will get quite a bit more static re: "high hours, it's going to need a rebuild soon so I'm deducting the price of that from my offer" than if you are offering a diesel boat for sale with the same number of hours on the meter.

Still, I think gas makes sense for most small boats and for those boaters that live in climates where it's frozen over a lot of the year and boats accumulate far fewer than 100 engine hours per annum.

Yesteday afternoon, I took a test run on a new boat that is just being introduced to the market. 33 feet, 6.0 litre gas engines. It's also available with diesels, but that option raises the price $50,000. At 33-feet it's still something of a toss-up, but for anything larger I still feel that for most folks diesel would be a better choice.

Chuck
May 15
On 15 May 2007 10:19:11 -0700, Chuck Gould Wayne.B
May 15
   

Disclaimer: This is a computer-generated and formatted feed of current postings to a public
Internet forum. We do not control the information delivered, nor do we endorse or monitor its
content. Internet forums may carry offensive, harmful, inaccurate, and otherwise inappropriate material.
Click to see the RSS XML version of this page   Click to see the Atom XML version of this page