Free Credit Report

Guide etiquette?

Question - when you hire a guide how much fishing should they be doing? I've had an experience that the guide was up in front of the boat running the trolling motor and I found nyself fishing used water quite a bit.
Steve
May 6
2005
My answer is simple.... NONE...

One of the reasons that I gave up on guides was their insistence on catching fish instead of paying any attention to the fisherman. Hell, if I wanted to pay somebody $350 to watch him fish..I must be nuts. Down here in So. Texas, some guides fish to catch the fish that the client wants to take home. Apparently teaching the client something is a forgotten talent.

I'll catch ( or miss ) my own. I always caught more fish with a guide ( they know where the fish are/were ) but...it just p%$#@# me off to watch them jerk fish in the boat from the bow. Who needs an expensive day of aggravation. I could tell you lots of "crummy guide " stories. I'm certain that there are a similar number of "crummy client" stories to be told, too...

RichG
May 7
A good guide won't fish at all unless the client issues the invitation. Ken
May 7
should they be doing? I've had an experience that the guide was up in front of the boat running the trolling motor and I found nyself fishing used water quite a bit."

I been on several guide trips before. I have had guides work the trolling motor and fish from the front and even had some that had a transom trolling motor and controlled it from the rear while fishing. If you book a guide make your expectations known and come to an agreement before you book.

I have had only one bad trip with a guide and it was not his fault. He tried to put us on fish but the wind and water conditions would not cooperate.

Sarge

Sarge
May 7
My son and I fish with a guide on the North Fork of the Susquehanna, a small PA river with a lot of fast water. My son and I work the bow all day long. Our guide (who has also become our friend) works the gas motor, the stern mounted electric motor, and the oars when in the fast water. He fishes, but only when our needs are fully addressed. We have learned a lot from watching him and listening to him. It never occurred to us that he should not fish, but this is probably because he knows how look after us first, and himself last.

I don't think there are hard and fast rules regarding "how to guide" other than the customer should be happy with the trip. Sounds like your guide put himself first. I hope you did not tip him, did not refer him to others, and I also hope you expressed your concerns to him regarding his treatment of you.

Sorry you had a bad day. We look forward to our guided trip every year as though it was Christmas Day looming.

Richard
May 7
I am a registered Maine Guide. I guide for smallmouth and stripers on the Kennebec River.

My position is that a guide should not be fishing unless an invitation is offered by the client and then never from the prime seat or into the prime lies, those are for paying clients, period. I spend time prospecting for the right places to put my clients on when I am out alone or with my partner.

The guides job is to put the clients on fish, not get paid to catch fish when out with a client.

Guides need to be watching the water, following the fish finders, managing the clients selection of baits, leaders, rigging and presentation so the clients gets on fish. Guides need to do the thinking part so the clients can do the enjoying part. Spinning a amusing story or two during slow times is the guides job, not actively fishing.

I operate my trolling motor from the center of my boat with clients on both the fore and aft platforms and when trolling run the kicker from the drivers seat. That way I can get to either client quickly if needed.

Any guide that does differently is not doing what your paying them to do, put YOU on fish.

Tight lines:

Mudfish\(Co30\)
May 9
I had a guide once on Lake Seminole that was more interested in fishing than putting us on fish.Plus he was late to show up and had all his rods rigged on the front deck.When I questioned him about that before we left the ramp he told us he was "looking" for fish for some friends of his in the next weeks Redman Tour. I told him we couldn't go out with him if that was the case and he was pissed.We had a boat with us and decided to cancel on him on the spot and fished from our own boat.When we came into Wingates for lunch he was still sitting around steaming,and it got worse when my partner weighed a 7+ on the scales there. Bass_Mr.
May 9
   

Disclaimer: This is a computer-generated and formatted feed of current postings to a public
Internet forum. We do not control the information delivered, nor do we endorse or monitor its
content. Internet forums may carry offensive, harmful, inaccurate, and otherwise inappropriate material.
Click to see the RSS XML version of this page   Click to see the Atom XML version of this page